ATP500 Barcelona 2024 - NADAL vs DE MINAUR

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    58

Znak

Hall of Fame
I don't really get why people take pleasure in seeing 38 year old greats lose (same goes for the other Big 4 for the avoidance of doubt). I kind of get it if they're much younger and playing peak tennis, but that's about it

These guys have given it their all over a 20-year career, they're at the tail end, coming off career-threatening injuries. Just seeing them compete is something special.
Likewise. They've done so much for the sport and yet they get spat on on their way out. People projecting their insecurities. And then they whine about tennis having no competitors.
 

mike danny

Bionic Poster
7-2 against Djoko, Nadal and Murray since January 2023.
andy-murray-scream.gif
 

ChaelAZ

G.O.A.T.
Thought Nadal would try to push things, but looked a bit more reserved and Alex was giving no slack. Again, Nadal and his team looked like this was in line for where they think Nadal is at, so that bodes well for RG. I do worry that Nadal is a very big confidence player, and I do think Barcelona was supposed to boost that, so a better showing and those issues are probably more than they hoped, or at least more than I thought we would see. But again, Alex is a BIG ask physically, which is the albatross around Nads neck right now.

I had Ruud in the finals in any case, so still plenty of good tennis to come.

RG will be one of the most unpredictable in a long while.
 

Phenomenal

Professional
Rafa is clearly on schedule no question. Now he has to build fitness and consistency
Rafa is not in his desirable schedule. He and his team was expecting him to be reaching close to his best possible level by this time at the start of year in Brisbane.
He needs to fix few things and it's not easy to do that.
 

messiahrobins

Hall of Fame
Rafa is not in his desirable schedule. He and his team was expecting him to be reaching close to his best possible level by this time at the start of year in Brisbane.
He needs to fix few things and it's not easy to do that.
He only decided Barcelona like 2 days ago lol.
 

Red Rick

Bionic Poster
I don't think anyone with a realistic outlook expected Rafa to win this match. It was a good warmup, testing his current abilities and a very, very decent first set by Rafa. The only way is up from here.
It's clay.

Nadal won 14 RGs, and De Minaur is pretty much a nothingburger player on the surface.
 

nolefam_2024

Talk Tennis Guru
Rafa is not in his desirable schedule. He and his team was expecting him to be reaching close to his best possible level by this time at the start of year in Brisbane.
He needs to fix few things and it's not easy to do that.
That's very unrealistic and unreasonable. I don't know why on god's green earth he played Brisbane. Should have directly started playing post AO.
 

GabeT

G.O.A.T.
2nd set was a car crash and will be interesting to hear why, was that deliberate to ease off or did he feel something.
Nadal made a lot of UEs from balls he didn’t even have to move to reach. it’s not like he only lost hard to get balls that required a lot of movement.
 

Neptune

Hall of Fame
ADM has won all matches against Rafa for the past full four years, hard and clay. LOL.

But if Rafa continues to gather more wins, he'll be just fine; he just needs time to get into form.
 

Phenomenal

Professional
It was expected. I wouldn't have surprised any result today. I don't think we will see Rafa close to his possible best before RG.
But Rafa is trying and slowly improving. Being able to play and increasing intensity is positive thing.

De minaur is nightmare with this type of Rafa whose only chance is being super agressive with his movement. Actually i thought he started well in second but Demon kept defending well.
 

messiahrobins

Hall of Fame
Not just BH. But maybe he did feel something. Only the team knows that
FH looked pretty good cross court and inside out, although DTLFH was way off. The BH and drop off in serve speed though is a concern for me as was De Minaur's body language at the end as he looked like an opponent who realised his opponent did something.
Be interesting to see what happens next.
 

Mustard

Bionic Poster
To me there will always be a fine line between forced and unforced errors. Is an error extracted from insane defense unforced or forced? Hard to tell.
There can be a fine line. Forced errors are definitely caused by the opponent forcing pressure on you into making a mistake, while unforced errors are when the player makes an unexpected error.
 

NaDjoFed

Rookie
I don't think anyone with a realistic outlook expected Rafa to win this match. It was a good warmup, testing his current abilities and a very, very decent first set by Rafa. The only way is up from here.

before the match started, more votes for Nadal winning. So yes, many people expected Nadal to win.
 

GabeT

G.O.A.T.
FH looked pretty good cross court and inside out, although DTLFH was way off. The BH and drop off in serve speed though is a concern for me as was De Minaur's body language at the end as he looked like an opponent who realised his opponent did something.
Be interesting to see what happens next.
When he hit the FH well you could see traces of the Nadal beast. But I also noticed too many UEs from the FH, particularly from balls that landed close to his feet. and other FHs were slower than usual, giving AdM time to reach them, which would not have happened with prior versions of Rafa.

We will have to wait and see. May be just the process of getting rid of the rust and gearing back up. Or maybe there‘s injury issues that won’t go away
 

Phenomenal

Professional
That's very unrealistic and unreasonable. I don't know why on god's green earth he played Brisbane. Should have directly started playing post AO.
Actually it was very positive just some bad luck.
He only decided Barcelona like 2 days ago lol.
Now of course It's positive that he played the event and he is on right track could have been worse too. But i'm saying that his team and he was not expecting to not play any tournaments after Brisbane. So againt it was setback. Don't think he played better than Brisbane now but he had countless issues.
I don't think he is worried at all by this match but overall we will see how fast or when he can improve his movement and other things.
 
Top