Debate: Is tennis the best sport?

eelhc

Hall of Fame
I enjoy Tennis very much (just got back into it after a long layoff).

However... at the recreational level... Absolutely the worst sport I've played. The poor attitudes, the lack of etiquette/decorum, bad sportsmanship, excessive gamesmanship/drama, etc, etc, etc... I sometimes wonder what it is about this sport that brings out the absolutely the worst in people.
 

Phoenix1983

G.O.A.T.
In-Arsene-We-Trust.png

The last time Arsenal won a trophy, Nadal had won 0 grand slams.
 

kOaMaster

Hall of Fame
I like tennis, I prefer football.
Main reason: atmosphere. everything around. the buzzing before the matches, sometimes days or weeks before.

personally, I love playing badminton and tennis is also great. couldn't imagine anything I love to play more myself. it just gives me a huge joy to play it and going broke while still maintaining a very high level of concentration.
but as a sport to watch and with everything around, I couldn't find anything that I'm more amazed than with football.
I guess what americans have with american football and some countries have with rugby is the next thing compared but not even remotely in the intensity.
 

cork_screw

Hall of Fame
Tennis is not the best sport. I think the level of entertainment is not consistent enough to warrant that title. It is only most entertaining when the top tier guys face each other, but I would say the majority of a tournament is not at an equal level in competition when top seeds face lower seeds. Some of the best matches happen in the semis and finals, but leading up to it, it gets boring and sometimes it drudges on and you lose interest in the match a little. I feel that way when i see fognini play as well as cilic and others who are mid-high seeds. Often times you'll watch matches and it's mainly a big server like Isner where all the points are mainly aces or short returns hit to winners by the server. Any match with Nadal, Djokovic or Federer are highly entertaining, but others fall below the bar that would make it complete enough to say that tennis is the best sport.

The best sport is American Football. American football has so many game changing factors and moments that are decided by seconds or single inches. So much strategy involved as well. The most highly watched shows of the past year have always been NFL play off games and of course the super bowl. Think about it this way, when do people gather around and watch games being decided in such a highly dense viewing audience where most of the audience aren't even represented from the teams that are actually playing. Even the World Series or NBA championships don't even come close to those numbers.
I can watch two bad teams like the Browns and Redskins play each other and still be highly entertained just by the factors that govern how a team must perform to beat another team. American football has some of the most high anxiety and high tension moments that come down to one play and may turn in an instant just by a few sequence of events. Every move changes the outcome of future plays in so many different ways. The concept of football is like a chess, it's also physical and brutal. This is the ultimate sport.

Football (soccer) comes in second as I love the anticipation of how goals are constructed and not knowing when a goal is going to get scored. Sometimes it happens in a blink of the eye when you least expect it and those moments catch you by surprise and have a little magic to them.

NBA basketball would be high up, but for me it's not as entertaining as it used to be back in the 80's through the early 2000's. They managed to change way too many rules trying to make it like College basketball by scrapping man to man and defaulting to zone defense. Calling too many fouls and not letting players play, but most egregious is allowing players to take advantage of the fouls called by purposely eliciting offensive fouls and flopping. If receivers were trying to dupe the officials to throw a flag by falling on the ground, the NFL would put a stop to it and penalize them for trying to bring the game down. The NBA on the other hand just rewards them for it by calling obvious flops or people stepping in to take an offensive foul a charge. To me that is pitiful that you can be rewarded for acting like you were fouled. That foul was originally meant to protect the player not to be used to dummy down the game. To me, the NBA has become so devolved from it's peak of the 80's and 90's much the same way that boxing seems to be deeply plagued by corruption and controlled by the promoters. Money has really ruined boxing. I love boxing as a sport, but the way it exists today has less to do about the sport than the business side of the sport.
 
Last edited:
N

Nathaniel_Near

Guest
I've tried repeatedly to get into American Football as a general sports lover but it just didn't happen.
 
D

Deleted member 21996

Guest
No. Nadal is the greatest sport. Nadal is also a great fragrance and some serious quality shirting!

now seriously.. what sort of question is this?
 

westside

Hall of Fame
Love playing it. Possibly my favourite sport to play with basketball at a close second.

To watch? I'll watch any AFL game ahead of a tennis match at the moment. NBA playoffs and the NCAA tournament come first as well.

Is it the best sport? Hard to make a claim like that. I grew up with AFL so I'll always prefer that.
 

Wynter

Legend
Love playing it. Possibly my favourite sport to play with basketball at a close second.

To watch? I'll watch any AFL game ahead of a tennis match at the moment. NBA playoffs and the NCAA tournament come first as well.

Is it the best sport? Hard to make a claim like that. I grew up with AFL so I'll always prefer that.

Absolutely disgusting mate ;)

Football/Soccer is where it will always be for me <3
 
Tennis is both the best sport to play and the best sport to watch. There are so many athletic elements to it. In addition, it's arguably the most international of sports. It's also an individual sport played indoors and outdoors year round. Then, you have the rich history to appreciate as well. For me, it's not even close.
 

Kirijax

Hall of Fame
From a television point of view, tennis doesn't allow television to go off for 5-minute commercial marathons like some sports do. Football and basketball drive me nuts with their constant timeouts and changing of sides. There are more commercial time than actual playing time. Watching baseball at the ball park is great, but it is one of the most boring sports on TV. Soccer is made for TV with their 45-minute no-break halves.
 

Bobby Jr

G.O.A.T.
The best sport is American Football. American football has so many game changing factors and moments that are decided by seconds or single inches. So much strategy involved as well...
The thing about American Football is that it is dominated mostly by morons who have an insanely low and narrow skillset. The genius of the game is in how they organise all those people and roles and have the plays so regimented/rehearsed. I don't enjoy that kind of set-up, I prefer one where it's each person doing the lot themselves and without the benefit of stopping for a pow-wow with the brains-trust of the organisation every 30 seconds while half the team is swapped out to make use of their special skillset for the next play.

The huge popularity you mentioned about American football, like soccer, is nothing to do with the skills of the sport but everything to do with how the average non-sporty person can relate to and enjoy the spectacle of it - as with NASCAR.

If being the biggest spectacle is what makes a sport 'the best' then soccer trumps American Football by miles. Best 'best' to me is more about what the sport entails at the level of each competitor and neither can hold a bar to tennis (or boxing for that matter) in terms of the rarity of combined skills/attributes required to be at the top of the game.
 

Kirijax

Hall of Fame
The thing about American Football is that it is dominated mostly by morons who have an insanely low and narrow skillset. The genius of the game is in how they organise all those people and roles and have the plays so regimented/rehearsed. I don't enjoy that kind of set-up, I prefer one where it's each person doing the lot themselves and without the benefit of stopping for a pow-wow with the brains-trust of the organisation every 30 seconds while half the team is swapped out to make use of their special skillset for the next play.

The huge popularity you mentioned about American football, like soccer, is nothing to do with the skills of the sport but everything to do with how the average non-sporty person can relate to and enjoy the spectacle of it - as with NASCAR.

If being the biggest spectacle is what makes a sport 'the best' then soccer trumps American Football by miles. Best 'best' to me is more about what the sport entails at the level of each competitor and neither can hold a bar to tennis (or boxing for that matter) in terms of the rarity of combined skills/attributes required to be at the top of the game.

Good post. You nailed it.
 

heftylefty

Hall of Fame
Tennis is both the best sport to play and the best sport to watch. There are so many athletic elements to it. In addition, it's arguably the most international of sports. It's also an individual sport played indoors and outdoors year round. Then, you have the rich history to appreciate as well. For me, it's not even close.

Ding, Ding Ding!
We have a winner!
 

Murray1337

Banned
Why I love watching tennis and why it's so addicting.

Have you ever found yourself rewatching highlights on youtube? Highlights of great matches that you've already seen before, perhaps multiple times in the past? And yet you find yourself watching the whole highlights video, up to 20-30 minutes long?

And that is why tennis is so awesome.

The players are charismatic, even those at the very top are still humble to a large extent, they are role models, the competition is INSANELY fierce and it's a the intensity can be cut with a knife sometimes, especially if you're watching a great match live. If a player loses a heartbreakingly close match, he/she goes home and has to deal with the loss and move on, tennis requires mental toughness and the depth of field is such that players always try 100%, which makes for such entertaining contests year round.

Not to mention tons of other things, like the diversity of players, playing styles, strokes, the unique energy that each player brings to the court, the diversity of tournaments, the awesome fans who are often, as evidenced by this forum, very well-spoken and articulate.

I can't even formulate a coherent paragraph here, since there's just too much to say.

Watching tennis, for me, never gets old because it's always a new, refreshing experience. Another week another tournament, new players winning, emerging, memorable moments, amazing shots, emotional moments, tennis matches are genuine, the players are genuine, and the fans appreciate the effort that the players put in just to get to the point where they are being seen on TV, we appreciate that they are working to hard and provide such great entertainment, we sympathize with their struggles, even the top ranked players, we can relate to them, they're cocky athletes who are expected to gloat after victories and trash talk, we like them as people, in addition to liking them as professional athletes.

I will not even proofread what I just wrote, so I apologize in advance for typos.

:)
 

Murray1337

Banned
Why I love watching tennis and why it's so addicting.

Have you ever found yourself rewatching highlights on youtube? Highlights of great matches that you've already seen before, perhaps multiple times in the past? And yet you find yourself watching the whole highlights video, up to 20-30 minutes long?

And that is why tennis is so awesome.

The players are charismatic, even those at the very top are still humble to a large extent, they are role models, the competition is INSANELY fierce and it's a the intensity can be cut with a knife sometimes, especially if you're watching a great match live. If a player loses a heartbreakingly close match, he/she goes home and has to deal with the loss and move on, tennis requires mental toughness and the depth of field is such that players always try 100%, which makes for such entertaining contests year round.

Not to mention tons of other things, like the diversity of players, playing styles, strokes, the unique energy that each player brings to the court, the diversity of tournaments, the awesome fans who are often, as evidenced by this forum, very well-spoken and articulate.

I can't even formulate a coherent paragraph here, since there's just too much to say.

Watching tennis, for me, never gets old because it's always a new, refreshing experience. Another week another tournament, new players winning, emerging, memorable moments, amazing shots, emotional moments, tennis matches are genuine, the players are genuine, and the fans appreciate the effort that the players put in just to get to the point where they are being seen on TV, we appreciate that they are working to hard and provide such great entertainment, we sympathize with their struggles, even the top ranked players, we can relate to them, they're not cocky athletes who are expected to gloat after victories and trash talk, we like them as people, in addition to liking them as professional athletes.

I will not even proofread what I just wrote, so I apologize in advance for typos.

:)

Oh my lord, stupid typo:

I meant to say they're not cocky, and I forgot the "not"

LOL
 

TopFH

Hall of Fame
Champions League? The most prestigious European competition. Hasn't been won by the same club in back-to-back years ever. Isn't this a sign of competitiveness?

Not entirely right, mate. Real Madrid won the first five UCLs in the 1950s. Bayern Munich and Milan have also won back-to-back titles. However, your point stands,as no one has won consecutive titles since 1990, not even clubs from the same nation. The completion is fierce there. Still, I think that the "curse" will be broken by Guardiola and his team.

I dare to say that the UCL is the best sports event on the planet. It has everything, including the best damn theme song of all.
 

Midaso240

Legend
Love playing it. Possibly my favourite sport to play with basketball at a close second.

To watch? I'll watch any AFL game ahead of a tennis match at the moment. NBA playoffs and the NCAA tournament come first as well.

Is it the best sport? Hard to make a claim like that. I grew up with AFL so I'll always prefer that.
That's funny,because to me,AFL just looks like a bunch of clowns running around kicking a ball through a bunch of posts with little structure to it. But then I guess to non-tennis fans,tennis is just a couple of morons hitting the ball back and forth over and over
 
Last edited:

Bobby Jr

G.O.A.T.
That's funny,because to me,AFL just looks like a bunch of clowns running around kicking a ball through a bunch of posts with little structure to it.
That's because it pretty much is, even if they are gifted athletes. You can tell the gauge the general level of player of a sport by how many of their top echelon are are arrested for drunk/disorderly, assault, petty crimes, recreational drug use/dealing. AFL is very accomplished in these areas.
 

kOaMaster

Hall of Fame
I just spent almost 3 days of the last week watching pro badminton live - it's very exciting.

the problem in here is: badminton is less popular than bowling in the US. and it's treated about the same way. as you said it's "fun to play" - well I assume you mean that thing you do with your girlfriend or at the beach which is nothing like badminton.
even in europe they have a hard standing, only in denmark it's probably 2nd popular sport (after football of course).
badminton is huge in asia, mainly in indonesia, china (nowadays dominating) and korea. recently, some other countries have drawn attention like india with saina nehwal as the most popular and highest paid sportsperson aside the cricket-players.
 

Russeljones

Talk Tennis Guru
Not entirely right, mate. Real Madrid won the first five UCLs in the 1950s. Bayern Munich and Milan have also won back-to-back titles. However, your point stands,as no one has won consecutive titles since 1990, not even clubs from the same nation. The completion is fierce there. Still, I think that the "curse" will be broken by Guardiola and his team.

I dare to say that the UCL is the best sports event on the planet. It has everything, including the best damn theme song of all.

I meant the CL and not the preceding format, obviously. You're right that there were streaks back then but that was the result of a real lack of depth in some domestic leagues (v.Basten/Guulit/Rijkard vs who?). Present day Champions League is incredibly well balanced. Even if I hate the group stage format with a passion! ;)
 

ed70

Professional
football was my first love, packed in playing when i was 41 due to achilles tendonitis constantly flaring up, i'ts a young mans game to play, Tennis on the other hand can be played well into later life especially doubles. As for watching for me it's Football that's no.1 although the diving & play acting spoils it for me, Rugby Union is a close 2nd, Boxing 3rd. As for Tennis i love playing but for me its like watching machines, there's very few characters, it was much better watching the borg, mcenroe connors era.
 

heftylefty

Hall of Fame
I grew up playing basketball. I loved playing basketball. It was the sport my father taught me to play and he was very good at. When I was a kid in the 70s the tennis boom started but it was a country club sport, and “real” athletes didn’t play tennis. My folk did introduced tennis to me in the summer of ’73.
It couldn’t compete with basketball for my attention.

Fast-forward to 1982. I am a senior and member of my varsity basketball who began to realize that my competitive basketball days were coming to an end. There wasn’t a market for a 6’2” power forward with no jump shot or ball handling skills. But by some strange fluke my mother was getting as subscription to Tennis Magazine. My mom doesn’t play tennis and didn’t recall ever sign up of a subscription for the magazine. So during my senior year I started reading about tennis. Back then Tennis Magazine was a great read. I thought to myself I can learn this game. I may not have been a great basketball player, but I was athletic. Once I took a tennis class in college I was hooked. I played every day. Mat Wilander and Chris Evert games I try to model.

What makes tennis the best sport in the world, for me at least, that it’s a sport of a lifetime. You can always get better. There is no riding the bench. You go as far as you talent and desire will take you. I have met some great people playing tennis.
 

Start da Game

Hall of Fame
no, it would be cricket.....cricket is very difficult for a lot of countries as the skill level required is very high and variables are too many to handle......most people in this world are too impatient to play the greatest game on the planet which is cricket......

p.s. cricket (and baseball too) originated from an ancient indian sport called gilli-danda......that's why india loves cricket and doesn't even care for any other sport invented by westerners......

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilli-danda
 

President

Legend
no, it would be cricket.....cricket is very difficult for a lot of countries as the skill level required is very high and variables are too many to handle......most people in this world are too impatient to play the greatest game on the planet which is cricket......

p.s. cricket (and baseball too) originated from an ancient indian sport called gilli-danda......that's why india loves cricket and doesn't even care for any other sport invented by westerners......

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilli-danda

Could Rafael Nadal and Pete Sampras have been great cricket players? What about Federer?
 

President

Legend
I grew up playing basketball. I loved playing basketball. It was the sport my father taught me to play and he was very good at. When I was a kid in the 70s the tennis boom started but it was a country club sport, and “real” athletes didn’t play tennis. My folk did introduced tennis to me in the summer of ’73.
It couldn’t compete with basketball for my attention.

Fast-forward to 1982. I am a senior and member of my varsity basketball who began to realize that my competitive basketball days were coming to an end. There wasn’t a market for a 6’2” power forward with no jump shot or ball handling skills. But by some strange fluke my mother was getting as subscription to Tennis Magazine. My mom doesn’t play tennis and didn’t recall ever sign up of a subscription for the magazine. So during my senior year I started reading about tennis. Back then Tennis Magazine was a great read. I thought to myself I can learn this game. I may not have been a great basketball player, but I was athletic. Once I took a tennis class in college I was hooked. I played every day. Mat Wilander and Chris Evert games I try to model.

What makes tennis the best sport in the world, for me at least, that it’s a sport of a lifetime. You can always get better. There is no riding the bench. You go as far as you talent and desire will take you. I have met some great people playing tennis.

What level did you finally reach? I always thought that many great basketball players would make great tennis players too, unlike a sport like football which doesn't really overlap that much. Many of the general skills and footwork patterns are kind of similar in basketball and tennis.
 

Start da Game

Hall of Fame
Could Rafael Nadal and Pete Sampras have been great cricket players? What about Federer?

federer has a south african mum so his cricketing skills should be fine......no idea how nadal and sampras would have fared, but they would have fought hard to master it for sure......
 

Kirijax

Hall of Fame
I read James Michner's description of cricket in one of his novels (maybe "South Africa") and I seemed to remember that basically it is difficult to understand cricket unless you grow up with it and are from a country that embraces it. He took several pages to explain it and I still didn't get it. lol
 

insideguy

G.O.A.T.
I read James Michner's description of cricket in one of his novels (maybe "South Africa") and I seemed to remember that basically it is difficult to understand cricket unless you grow up with it and are from a country that embraces it. He took several pages to explain it and I still didn't get it. lol


I have watched a decent amount of sports in my time. And although every game has its weird rules and things that dont make sense right away, Cricket is the only sport where I have no clue wtf they are doing or attempting to accomplish lol.
 

Bobby Jr

G.O.A.T.
....that's why india loves cricket and doesn't even care for any other sport invented by westerners...
Field hockey was long considered the national game of India. It still is unofficially alongside cricket.

They've even won more Olympic golds in Hockey than they have World Cups in Cricket (the top achievement in each)
 

HRB

Hall of Fame
Extremely subjective and personal opinionated type of question.

My "two cents" is simply this...tennis is my favorite SOLO (sorry folks...doubles is for socializing) sport to watch and play...Basketball is my Favorite team sport to watch and play.

The value of a team sport is you learn to work with others, to be responsible for your job, to do your best for the good of others...extreme translation value to the corporate work force. The drawback...sometimes your success or failure is predicated on the efforts or lack thereof from others, no matter what you do!

On the other hand with a solo sport like tennis, all the motivation, all the effort, all the focus has to come from within...sure, all the glory goes to you, but so does all the blame! Crosses over greatly to real world experience as an entrepreneur or private practice professional or independent sales rep.

Both of these scenarios can be found in these two great complimentary sports...and they happen to be my favorites...BUT...someone else may love Golf and Soccer (futbal) and get the same benefits.
 
Last edited:
Top