Sinner vs. Alcaraz China Open SF 2023

Who will win?

  • Jannik in 2

    Votes: 9 28.1%
  • Jannik in 3

    Votes: 9 28.1%
  • Carlitos in 2

    Votes: 7 21.9%
  • Carlitos in 3

    Votes: 7 21.9%

  • Total voters
    32

marc45

G.O.A.T.
well, we got Sinner, Zverev, and Medvedev all in the same quarter in Shanghai I believe?

so Carlos can avoid two until the final
 
Last edited:

Kralingen

Talk Tennis Guru
Carlos is still far from his best on HC I think.

The problem solving against depth just isn’t there, it’s brute force and not enough adaption. He also gets frustrated very easily when not dominating.
 

robyrolfo

Hall of Fame
He brings it against Alcaraz for some reason and it seems Alcaraz can't handle him. The only player really to make Alcaraz look this vulnerable. Incredible.
I agree that for some reason, this is a particularly bad matchup for Alcaraz, but some of you speak like Sinner plays like completely garbage against everyone else. That's simply not the case. Yes, he gets tight in some big spots and isn't always super dominant, but he's a very good player.

Miami 2023 redux?
Let's hope not. Not sure how Sinner was feeling, but his Miami semi against Carlos was a long and grueling match. This second set is exactly what Sinner needed.
 

Baseline_Bungle

Hall of Fame
4 wins over the super-future-mega-goat. With 4 tasty tyrolean breadsticks. He has now beaten Ratz at all 4 levels of ATP play: 250, 500, 1000 and slam. Tomorrow, he'll be world number 4.

"Not too bad"... 4 a perennially injured choking mental midget with no serve, no slice, no touch, no net game, no legs, no personality and no chance.

What a performance!
 

RF-18

Talk Tennis Guru
I agree that for some reason, this is a particularly bad matchup for Alcaraz, but some of you speak like Sinner plays like completely garbage against everyone else. That's simply not the case. Yes, he gets tight in some big spots and isn't always super dominant, but he's a very good player.


Let's hope not. Not sure how Sinner was feeling, but his Miami semi against Carlos was a long and grueling match. This second set is exactly what Sinner needed.

Obviously he is an incredible player but there are some players he has issues with wich I find a bit weird. He has major problems against Medvedev for example (0-5 I believe) and also Zverev but he handles Alcaraz like a boss. If he can play like this against Alcaraz I don't see why he can't against Medvedev or even Djokovic for that matter.
 

Benf15harp

Hall of Fame
4 wins over the super-future-mega-goat. With 4 tasty tyrolean breadsticks. He has now beaten Ratz at all 4 levels of ATP play: 250, 500, 1000 and slam. Tomorrow, he'll be world number 4.

"Not too bad"... 4 a perennially injured choking mental midget with no serve, no slice, no touch, no net game, no legs, no personality and no chance.

What a performance!
Doesn’t take much variety to defeat a midget
 

Baseline_Bungle

Hall of Fame
How many short backhands up the line (undefended) has Sinner missed?
Yes, he missed a few bad ones here and there - but never let it cost him. Overall, as close to perfect as I've ever seen him. And I've seen pretty much every one of his matches since Feb '19.
 

rigged

Rookie
Every ATP match of them went to a tie-break.
Every match of them had the spaniard as the favorite, yet Sinner is the only player to defeat Alcaraz 4 times (and he defeated him on every surface). If he's gonna be a multiple slam wnner, I swear that this is gonna be from the confidence he got by beating Alcaraz.
 

Krish0608

G.O.A.T.
Sinner is always going to be a tough matchup. And on top of that’s, Carlos has been on fumes since the American HC began. He’s nowhere close to the level he showed in the early to mid parts of the year. That Wimbledon win seems to have taken more out of Carlos than expected. This is poor from Alcaraz.
 

top10

Semi-Pro
It's best that Alcaraz rest up for Shanghai. Needs to heal his left leg. Year end number 1 is still on the line.
He better do better than semi in Shanghai or he may need to beat Djokovic (maybe twice) in Paris and Rome to get the Year End #1
 

paolo2143

Professional
yep Sinner definitely seems to be kryptonite to Carlos at times, never seen Carlos look as clueless or out his depth against Novak so clearly as well as potential match up issue i think Janik is in his head a bit.
 

FeroBango

Hall of Fame
That sums it up, but Sinner was better than just mediocre today.
He was alright but I've seen him play better even against Alcaraz. He was down a break two times in set 1, lost the minibreaks in the TB, and even faced 3 break-back points in the breadstick set. He sprayed errors when Alcaraz remotely mixed things up.

If Alcaraz had not gone down the "who's the man" route, Sinner's true level would have been fully exposed today.
 

robyrolfo

Hall of Fame
Obviously he is an incredible player but there are some players he has issues with wich I find a bit weird. He has major problems against Medvedev for example (0-5 I believe) and also Zverev but he handles Alcaraz like a boss. If he can play like this against Alcaraz I don't see why he can't against Medvedev or even Djokovic for that matter.
I could be as simply as Medvedev playing a few feet/meters further behind the baseline, allowing him to return more of Sinner's shots, while Alcaraz doesn't want to move back. But it seems clear that Alcaraz does better against Medvedev because he is willing (and more than able) to go to the net to finish points. Sinner just said in his interview that he will try some new things, so let's hope...

Yes, he missed a few bad ones here and there - but never let it cost him. Overall, as close to perfect as I've ever seen him. And I've seen pretty much every one of his matches since Feb '19.
Yes, he looked composed today, even in the tighter spots or when things were going his way. I'm confident he will continue to mature mentally and physically.

Sinner is always going to be a tough matchup. And on top of that’s, Carlos has been on fumes since the American HC began. He’s nowhere close to the level he showed in the early to mid parts of the year. That Wimbledon win seems to have taken more out of Carlos than expected. This is poor from Alcaraz.
Seems to be the case, but Carlos also skipped the entire Australian swing to start the year. Given he is only 20, and hasn't played the full calendar, he should be pretty fresh physically.
 

Baseline_Bungle

Hall of Fame
Obviously he is an incredible player but there are some players he has issues with wich I find a bit weird. He has major problems against Medvedev for example (0-5 I believe) and also Zverev but he handles Alcaraz like a boss. If he can play like this against Alcaraz I don't see why he can't against Medvedev or even Djokovic for that matter.
Med and Zed can absorb the pace and go for hours from the back with him, especially on that BH diagonal which is Sinner's real strong point. He's always had issues with that type of counterpuncher - for crying out loud, he lost like 4 times to Bedene... Ratz on the other hand has much more variety but can get impatient. And for some reason, he seems to find Ratz's ball better than ne does with those two, perhaps cause it has a little more shape to it. Also, at the end of the day, Muscle Boy's serve is just not as dominant as the two tall Russians. But as I've said long ago: slowly yet steadily, the Mountain Boy will catch up to those two - as he has with Tsits. And eventually, he will leave them both in the rear view mirror.
 

Cerdany

Semi-Pro
Bang average match. Sinner was mediocre. Alcaraz was worse.

It's an ego issue for Alcaraz. No Carlos, you're not a bigger hitter than Sinner. Play your game, not Sinner's next time.

This. Carlitos is not a bigger hitter than Jannik but tries to be and that leads to too many errors.

That's the genius of Djokovic. He understood early in his career that he wasn't going to outhit anyone, so he developed a percentages game that fits his strokes and consistency. Now imagine if Carlitos can do that.
 

NYTennisfan

Professional
this is like saying hurkacz is better than Rog because they’re 1-1. Makes zero sense.
Yeah except for the fact that Alcaraz was/is #1 in the world and won 2 slams while Hurkacz is barely a top 20 player that has done nothing of note but, yeah, that's the same.

Djokovic had the better year and is the top dog still so I'm not arguing that ftr but h2h they've been as even as can be. The margins are thin between the two.
 

Kralingen

Talk Tennis Guru
4 wins over the super-future-mega-goat. With 4 tasty tyrolean breadsticks. He has now beaten Ratz at all 4 levels of ATP play: 250, 500, 1000 and slam. Tomorrow, he'll be world number 4.

"Not too bad"... 4 a perennially injured choking mental midget with no serve, no slice, no touch, no net game, no legs, no personality and no chance.

What a performance!
Your jinxing powers are approaching mine own.

Happy for you guys though. However, this is nothing that hasn’t happened before - the real challenge comes tomorrow.
 
Top